Author, Jim Malone, Workers’ Compensation Claims Advocate, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.
There are many things the employer is required to do after a work related injury occurs. There are also additional things an employer can and should do after an employee is injured, though not required by any regulatory agency, like offering modified work.
Obviously, there is the immediate need to address the injury itself. This is usually done by the lead, foreman, or supervisor and would include stopping the bleeding, placing ice on the injured area, etc. The injured worker’s injury then needs to be assessed by a medical professional. There are options for having the injury medically assessed. For minor injuries, it may be by calling a triage service or having a medical triage specialist (nurse or paramedic) go to the injured worker to determine if this minor injury can be taken care of with self-care or if the injured worker needs to be seen at an occupational medicine clinic. With referring your injured worker to a clinic, you should determine if the injured worker can drive themselves or if they need a company representative to drive them.
After the injury is properly addressed, focus on the reporting of the claim. Gather the forms and reports that need to be completed or obtained to provide to the insurance adjuster. Your next decision comes after the treating physician completes their initial evaluation. The physician should provide doctor notes, the mechanism of injury, how the injury occurred, and any other additional information. The physician may also provide wound care, sutures, x-rays, ace wraps, medications, ointments and make referrals for physical therapy, acupuncture and/or chiropractic treatment, etc.
The treating physician then provides their recommendations on the injured worker’s ability to return to work. For more severe injuries, the treating physician may want the injured worker to remain off work completely and could recommend temporary total disability. After some time off work and with some provided treatment, the doctor usually recommends that the injured worker return to work, but with some restrictions, such as not lifting over a certain amount of weight, not exceeding so many hours of weight bearing, etc. The restrictions provided are usually consistent with the body part(s) that were injured.
So, the treating physician is releasing the injured worker to return to work but not to full, physical capacity. This is called a release to modified work, restricted duties, or light duties. From the insurance claims perspective, this is referred to as temporary partial disability. The modified work restrictions are usually slowly decreased while the injured worker continues the treatments and recovers from the work injury. This gradual recovery continues until the injured worker is able to resume all their physical work activities. This is called being released to full work activities, unrestricted duties, or to their usual and customary duties.
When the injured worker is released to modified work (i.e., restricted, light) duties, the employer decides if they can provide the injured employee duties that allows them to work while avoiding certain physical activities consistent with the doctor’s return to work recommendations.
Benefits to the Employee
Providing modified, restricted, light duty work serves many purposes. First and foremost, providing modified work can reassure an injured worker that their employer cares for them personally, professionally, and psychologically. A work injury can be a very traumatic event, and returning to work as soon as possible after a work injury can help the injured worker feel confident their employer will be there for them and their family as they recover from the accident. This is one of the ways the employer can show their support of, and gratitude for, their employees and all the hard work they provide.
Many studies have shown that providing modified work results in injured workers recovering quicker and more completely. It allows the injured worker to maintain their earnings and usual working schedule, while maintaining their relationships with the foreman, supervisors, and co-workers. Modified work also allows the injured employee to remain physically and mentally active while also allowing them to focus on their treatment and recovery.
Effect on the Business
For a business, a work injury can be very disruptive. The disruption of a work injury usually causes employers to move employees around to compensate for a lost employee. Employees working together as a team would see a change in work partners. Crews would be short a person who would be responsible for a certain part of an assignment resulting in changes in each crew member’s responsibilities. A work injury may affect how quickly the team can complete a job or project, how quickly the crew completes their daily tasks, and even how the employer is able to bid on future jobs or projects.
Work injuries are stressful for an employer and the remaining employees. Besides the lost productivity from an injured worker, there may also be an emotional strain to other employees, or concerns about their own safety, about how they would be able to handle such an injury or how they would be treated if they were injured.
Assigning an injured worker to modified work allows the employer to address other items of their business that may not get addressed when all employees are working at full capacity or when there are not enough employees to address these other areas. Assigning an injured worker to modified duties can allow an employer get caught up on cleaning certain areas, re-organizing a storeroom, updating inventory, etc.
Benefits to the Business
Providing modified work allows an employer to have a direct impact on the overall cost of a work-related injury claim. By providing modified work, the employer pays the injured worker’s wages instead of the claims adjuster paying temporary disability benefits. If the employer does not offer modified work for an injured worker, instead of being temporarily partially disabled, the injured worker is then considered temporarily totally disabled. The claims adjuster would then be required to pay the injured worker temporary disability benefits at 2/3 of the injured worker’s average weekly wage. This is calculated from the 52 weeks of previous earning information you provide the adjuster when the claim was being created. This is also a tax-free benefit.
However, getting these temporary disability benefits can also be a disincentive for injured workers to return to their normal work duties sooner than they are required. There is an increasing trend of injured workers refusing to return to modified work offered by their employers. Whether they want to stay home and collect temporary disability benefits, complete a side job they were working on while concurrently working for the employer, or if they believe they will recover quicker by simply staying home, injured workers can make it difficult to provide modified work. They can be disruptive, argumentative and provide poor quality of work while performing modified work. They can be insubordinate while performing modified work and can arrive late, leave early, take too much time for doctor or treatment appointments, etc. They can frustrate the employer so much that the employer may want to reconsider offering modified work to this injured worker. If the employee declines the employer’s modified work offer, the injured worker would no longer receive any wages from the employer and they would not be entitled to any temporary disability benefits/payments from the adjuster.
Injured workers retain legal counsel for work-related injuries for a wide variety of reasons. Disagreements over returning to modified work is one of the most common of these reasons. When an attorney becomes involved in a workers’ compensation claim, there are usually disagreements over a number of issues, but the modified work dispute from the attorney is usually that the employer did not properly advise or instruct the injured worker about their responsibilities related to modified work offers.
The lost time from work issue, after modified work is declined by the injured worker, usually becomes a monetary issue that is documented at the time, then later becomes one of the issues to negotiate or resolve when the claim is being settled. Usually a dispute like this is negotiated somewhere between the full value of the time lost from work and zero. This adds to the overall cost of a workers’ compensation claim. The development of this issue, however, can be completely avoided if the employer were to document the offer of modified work in writing. The employer can draft their own offer of modified work letter. The claims adjuster, their return to work specialists, or your claims advocate can also provide assistance with drafting of this letter.
When an injured worker declines modified work offers, they sometimes get state disability benefits from the State of California Employment Develop Department (EDD), who in turn file a lien (or bill) for the lost time benefits paid to the injured worker on the workers’ compensation claim. If the attorney and the claims adjuster are unable to resolve this issue, the documentation obtained (The Modified Work Offer letter) when the modified work was offered will usually be sufficient evidence for not reimbursing EDD for any of their lien, and/or for the workers’ compensation judge to agree with the employer and claims adjuster on this issue.
Offering modified work is a very good thing to do for injured workers, for their recovery, and for the employer. It is also a very effective and proven strategy for handling workers’ compensation claims. Offering modified work can speed up the injured worker’s recovery. This allows the workers’ compensation claim to move quicker through the claim process to resolution or settlement. This usually results in the injured worker’s return to their normal work activities, their continued employment with the employer, and in reducing the cost of the workers’ compensation claim.